Promissory Estoppel Examples in Real Estate

In the world of contracts, a promise can become an enforceable part of a contract if it causes one of the parties to change their position in a substantial way because of it. Even though these promises made might not be written in the physical contract, they are considered promissory estoppels. False promises can therefore be taken to court and the promise can be enforced for its market value. In real estate, this is often seen during the negotiation phase of a mortgage or in the enforcement of a lease. A landlord might promise to fix a water heater if a tenant will sign a lease, but then not fix the water heater at all. A property owner might offer someone a percentage of a home's sale to complete a repair, but then never sell the home. In each instance, the injured party would be entitled to compensation because the promise was left unfulfilled.

Why Are Promissory Estoppels Important To Know About?

The courts treat a promise as a verbal contract. They have the same weight and power as a written contract from a legal standpoint. If a tenant or potential buyer of a home takes specific actions because they were given a promise by a landlord or a current property owner, then this is often enough evidence to support the existence of the verbal promise. From a rental standpoint, the condition of the security deposit becomes one of the biggest places of dispute when it comes to promissory estoppels. If a property manager were to tell a tenant to not worry about cleaning up a property upon moving out, then the tenant would likely leave the property in whatever condition it happened to be in when they moved out. Under a standard written lease, portions of the security deposit could be withheld to prepare the property for a new tenant. This changes because of the promise made: “You don't have to worry about cleaning up the property to move out.” The contract stipulations have been verbally modified by the property manager and created a specific behavior from the tenant. Any cleaning charges would then become the liability of the landlord or property manager. Some courts might even consider “cleaning up” to include repairs.

It Is Always Important To Watch What Is Said

Words come back to haunt landlords and property managers more often than not and it is usually in simple ways. Sometimes something as simple as a “yes” to a question a tenant has is enough to create promissory estoppels. If a property owner doesn't allow pets and a management company tells a pet-owning household that they should apply for a lease on that property, then it could be ruled that pets must be allowed and compensation could be awarded for denial of this. A tenant or a buyer does not need to take possession of a property to be awarded a promissory estoppel. As long as one party endures a cost of time, labor, or money because of a false promise made by the other party, then compensation may be legally due. Promissory estoppels also work both ways. If a tenant makes a promise that causes a landlord or property manager to take specific actions, then compensation could also be due. This doctrine has been in US law for generations and for good reason: a false promise could be used to create favorable contract conditions for one party and not the other. By making sure everyone stays honest, fair compensation can result more often.

Posted on Dec 29, 2014


Tips on Buying Real Estate for Rental Income

There are five basic types of real estate investments properties: Residential – single family homes to rent or rollover Commercial – Apartments and office buildings Domestic vacation – In the US:... More

Section 179 Deduction Rental Property?

Depreciation is one of the nicest aspects of owning a rental property. Over the course of 27.5 years, you can take out the true value of your investment until you completely recover the amount you... More

Self Directed IRA Rental Property

Most people let a third-party manage their IRA, but this doesn't have to be the case. A self-directed IRA might not be very well known, but it is an effective way to build up a nice nest egg for a... More

Selling A Rental Property With Tenants

Selling a rental property with tenants may be very straightforward; having a tenant in place can make for an unpleasant selling experience. Most real estate professionals will recommend allowing a... More

How To Invest In Rental Property Using An IRA

Real estate has proven to be one of the most reliable long term investments, so it's not surprising that many investors make real estate a core part of their retirement planning. But many people... More

The Eviction Process in New York City

Evictions in New York City generally fall into two distinct categories, and each has its own process that must be followed precisely by the landlord. The most common reason for eviction is nonpayment... More

Buying Your Next Great Investment Property

Whether it's early on or down the road of your property management career, at some point you may start looking to expand the number of properties you hold. When buying a property, how can you be... More

What You Need To Know About Utah's Housing Boom

When the United States' real estate bubble burst in 2007, it hurt real estate markets throughout the country. Many are still recovering, but some have bounced back faster than others.  One of... More

Best Markets for Buying New Properties

After the real estate market turbulence of the last several years, investors are much more choosy about where and when they buy property, and rightly so. Some of the nation's top metropolitan... More

5 Cities Where it's Great to be a Landlord

According to the 2014 third quarter report from RealtyTrac, there are several cities across the country where it's great to be a landlord. Some cities offer lower risk for landlords seeking to... More